[beendet] Große FT: 9x Distillers Edition

krimoldo

Beim Übertragen ist vorhin etwas nich richtig gelaufen, daher hier noch ergänzt:

Caol Ila Distillers Edition 2001/2013, 43%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
Atzenking 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl

Rest: 14cl
______________________________________________

Clynelish Distillers Edition 1997/2011, 46%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl

Rest: 28cl
______________________________________________

Cragganmore Distillers Edition 1998/2012, 40%
4cl = 3,50€ / 10cl = 8,00€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JEns0815 - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl

Rest: 20cl
______________________________________________

Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition 1992/2010, 43%
4cl = 3,70€ / 10cl = 8,40€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JoePitt 10cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl

Rest: 8cl
______________________________________________

Glenkinchie Distillers Edition 1996/2011, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl

Rest: 18cl
______________________________________________

Lagavulin Distillers Edition 1995/2013, 43%
4cl = 4,70€ / 10cl = 11,00€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl

Rest: 38cl
______________________________________________

Oban Distillers Edition 1997/2012, 43%
4cl = 3,80€ / 10cl = 8,50€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl

Rest: 4cl
______________________________________________

Royal Lochnagar Distillers Edition 1996/2009, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl

Rest: 22cl
______________________________________________

Talisker Distillers Edition 2002/2013, 45,8%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Jens0815 - 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl

Rest: 12cl

niggy1813

Hab ich es verdaddelt? Dann tut es mir Leid!

Und weiter geht's

Unbekannt

Ich nehm' auch noch was...

Caol Ila Distillers Edition 2001/2013, 43%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
Atzenking 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl

Rest: 4cl
______________________________________________

Clynelish Distillers Edition 1997/2011, 46%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 24cl
______________________________________________

Cragganmore Distillers Edition 1998/2012, 40%
4cl = 3,50€ / 10cl = 8,00€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JEns0815 - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 16cl
______________________________________________

Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition 1992/2010, 43%
4cl = 3,70€ / 10cl = 8,40€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JoePitt 10cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 4cl
______________________________________________

Glenkinchie Distillers Edition 1996/2011, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 14cl
______________________________________________

Lagavulin Distillers Edition 1995/2013, 43%
4cl = 4,70€ / 10cl = 11,00€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl

Rest: 28cl
______________________________________________

Oban Distillers Edition 1997/2012, 43%
4cl = 3,80€ / 10cl = 8,50€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: NIX
______________________________________________

Royal Lochnagar Distillers Edition 1996/2009, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 18cl
______________________________________________

Talisker Distillers Edition 2002/2013, 45,8%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Jens0815 - 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl

Rest: 2cl

michaelsch

dabei

Caol Ila Distillers Edition 2001/2013, 43%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
Atzenking 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl
michaelsch - 4cl

Rest: NIX
______________________________________________

Clynelish Distillers Edition 1997/2011, 46%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 14cl
______________________________________________

Cragganmore Distillers Edition 1998/2012, 40%
4cl = 3,50€ / 10cl = 8,00€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JEns0815 - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 6cl
______________________________________________

Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition 1992/2010, 43%
4cl = 3,70€ / 10cl = 8,40€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JoePitt 10cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 4cl
______________________________________________

Glenkinchie Distillers Edition 1996/2011, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 4cl
______________________________________________

Lagavulin Distillers Edition 1995/2013, 43%
4cl = 4,70€ / 10cl = 11,00€

niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 18cl
______________________________________________

Oban Distillers Edition 1997/2012, 43%
4cl = 3,80€ / 10cl = 8,50€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: NIX
______________________________________________

Royal Lochnagar Distillers Edition 1996/2009, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 8cl
______________________________________________

Talisker Distillers Edition 2002/2013, 45,8%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Jens0815 - 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl

Rest: 2cl
vom Talisker würd ich auch noch 4cl oder 10cl nehmen wenn es eine zweite flasche gibt. ansonsten ok für mich.

michaelsch

achso:
würd noch drei samples je 4cl von dir dazunehmen:
Ben Nevis 20 Jahre - 1992/2012, Signatory Vintage, 46% ( 3,20€ / 7,20€ )
Kilchoman Machir Bay, 46% ( 3,00€ / 6,70€ )
Glenlivet French Oak 15 Jahre, 40% ( 2,50€ / 5,50€ )

niggy1813

An manchen Flaschen schein ja großes Interesse zu sein. Deshalb würde ich mich doch entschließen, jeweils auch eine 2. Flasche zu teilen. Allerdings gilt auch hier, dass weniger als 4cl Rest übrig bleiben, damit die Teilung zu Stande kommt.

Ab heute bin ich bis Sonntag leider offline, mal sehen, was sich bis dahin ergibt.

michaelsch trage ich beim Talisker mal mit 10cl ein. Wenn du doch nur 4cl möchtest, dann ändere es einfach ab.

Und hier nun die Listen mit den Einträgen aus dem Nachbarforum

Caol Ila Distillers Edition 2001/2013, 43%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
Atzenking 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl
michaelsch - 4cl

Rest: NIX

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Clynelish Distillers Edition 1997/2011, 46%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 14cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Cragganmore Distillers Edition 1998/2012, 40%
4cl = 3,50€ / 10cl = 8,00€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JEns0815 - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 6cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition 1992/2010, 43%
4cl = 3,70€ / 10cl = 8,40€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JoePitt 10cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 4cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Glenkinchie Distillers Edition 1996/2011, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 4cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Lagavulin Distillers Edition 1995/2013, 43%
4cl = 4,70€ / 10cl = 11,00€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 18cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Oban Distillers Edition 1997/2012, 43%
4cl = 3,80€ / 10cl = 8,50€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: NIX

FLASCHE 2
RudolfR - 4cl

Rest: 66cl
______________________________________________

Royal Lochnagar Distillers Edition 1996/2009, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 8cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Talisker Distillers Edition 2002/2013, 45,8%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Jens0815 - 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl

Rest: 2cl

FLASCHE 2
michaelsch - 10cl
RudolfR - 10cl

Rest: 50cl

TD73

Caol Ila Distillers Edition 2001/2013, 43%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
Atzenking 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl
michaelsch - 4cl

Rest: NIX

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Clynelish Distillers Edition 1997/2011, 46%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 14cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Cragganmore Distillers Edition 1998/2012, 40%
4cl = 3,50€ / 10cl = 8,00€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JEns0815 - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 6cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition 1992/2010, 43%
4cl = 3,70€ / 10cl = 8,40€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JoePitt 10cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 4cl

FLASCHE 2
TD73 - 10cl
Rest: 60cl
______________________________________________

Glenkinchie Distillers Edition 1996/2011, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 4cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Lagavulin Distillers Edition 1995/2013, 43%
4cl = 4,70€ / 10cl = 11,00€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 18cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Oban Distillers Edition 1997/2012, 43%
4cl = 3,80€ / 10cl = 8,50€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: NIX

FLASCHE 2
RudolfR - 4cl
TD73 - 10cl

Rest: 56cl
______________________________________________

Royal Lochnagar Distillers Edition 1996/2009, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 8cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Talisker Distillers Edition 2002/2013, 45,8%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Jens0815 - 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl

Rest: 2cl

FLASCHE 2
michaelsch - 10cl
RudolfR - 10cl

Rest: 50cl

TD73

Kurze Zwischenfrage an die Experten:

ich habe bei allen 9 Whisky zugeschlagen und möchte an drei Abenden jeweils 3 Whiskys probieren.

Aber, in welcher Reihenfolge?

Mika

Caol Ila Distillers Edition 2001/2013, 43%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
Atzenking 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl
michaelsch - 4cl

Rest: NIX

FLASCHE 2
Mika - 10cl

Rest: 60cl
______________________________________________

Clynelish Distillers Edition 1997/2011, 46%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl
Mika - 10cl

Rest: 4cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Cragganmore Distillers Edition 1998/2012, 40%
4cl = 3,50€ / 10cl = 8,00€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JEns0815 - 4cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl
Mika - 4 cl (gern auch 10cl wenn es eine 2. Flasche gibt)

Rest: 2 cl

FLASCHE 2


Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Dalwhinnie Distillers Edition 1992/2010, 43%
4cl = 3,70€ / 10cl = 8,40€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
OliverMarcus - 10cl (i.A.)
JoePitt 10cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: 4cl

FLASCHE 2
TD73 - 10cl
Mika - 10cl
Rest: 50cl
______________________________________________

Glenkinchie Distillers Edition 1996/2011, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl
Mika - 4cl

Rest: 0cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Lagavulin Distillers Edition 1995/2013, 43%
4cl = 4,70€ / 10cl = 11,00€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
marcz - 4cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl
michaelsch - 10cl
Mika - 10cl

Rest: 8cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Oban Distillers Edition 1997/2012, 43%
4cl = 3,80€ / 10cl = 8,50€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Lolo - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Jens0815 - 4cl
Atzenking 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
cordwalter - 4cl

Rest: NIX

FLASCHE 2
RudolfR - 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
Mika - 10cl

Rest: 46cl
______________________________________________

Royal Lochnagar Distillers Edition 1996/2009, 43%
4cl = 3,40€ / 10cl = 7,70€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 4cl
JoePitt 10cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 4cl
michaelsch - 10cl

Rest: 8cl

FLASCHE 2

Rest: 70cl
______________________________________________

Talisker Distillers Edition 2002/2013, 45,8%
4cl = 3,60€ / 10cl = 8,10€

FLASCHE 1
niggy1813 - 10cl
umo1 10cl
marcz - 10cl
Jens0815 - 10cl
krimoldo - 4cl
Atlex 4cl
TD73 - 10cl
cordwalter - 10cl

Rest: 2cl

FLASCHE 2
michaelsch - 10cl
RudolfR - 10cl

Rest: 50cl

Unbekannt

Hi,

"TD73" schrieb:
ich habe bei allen 9 Whisky zugeschlagen und möchte an drei Abenden jeweils 3 Whiskys probieren.

Aber, in welcher Reihenfolge?

Denkbar wäre z.B. jeweils eine Reihe:
Leicht - Aromatisch/Kräftig - Rauchig

Kenne nicht alle DEs, aber von Grundcharakter der Malts ausgehend:
1. Glenkinchie - Cragganmore - Talisker
2. Oban - Clynelish - Caol Ila
3. Dalwhinnie - Royal Lochnagar - Lagavulin

Ich würde die Reihe dann übrigens "parallel" verkosten, also alle in Gläser füllen, alle verriechen, dann jeweils kosten. Manchmal ergeben sich überraschende Geschmacksnuancen, wenn man von einem Rauchigen zu einem nicht-Rauchigen zurückgeht ...